Cassie Gustafson’s The Secrets We Keep delves into the emotional journey of Emma, a high school freshman faced with piecing together the truths about her family’s past. When her best friend accuses her father of sexual misconduct, she must confront dire shifts in her closest relationships and decide where her loyalty lies.

Emma writes “fairy tales” to cope with her loneliness, which are dispersed throughout the novel and provide an allegorical illustration of loss and rupture in trust. Within these nightmarish fragments, the reader gets a unique glimpse into a teenage girl’s anxious inner landscape. Meanwhile, the text shifts between accounts of Emma’s painful present-day social interactions surrounding the accusation and her repressed memories, including the scandal that drove her family from San Francisco to rural Oregon. Each vignette reveals poignant bits of information to build a cohesive and direct commentary about the webs of abuse. Though the plot is sometimes predictable and lacks complexity, Gustafon’s story-telling technique unfolds as a nuanced and dimensional study of intimacy and the psyche in grief. Thoughtful of the trauma some people already have experienced in their lives, she also gives readers a warning that the story may be a trigger for some as well as a list of support organizations at the end. Recommended for high school libraries.