Silverwing: The Graphic Novel Adaptation, based on the first novel in Kenneth Oppel’s beloved trilogy, brings the adventurous tale of the young, heroic bat Shade to life with vivid illustrations. I was excited to add this adaptation to our collection, anticipating it would capture the interest and imaginations of our students. While the artwork is indeed captivating and adds a new dimension to the story, I’ve noticed that some students find it challenging to follow the narrative in this graphic format.
The primary issue seems to be the pacing and transition between scenes. The graphic novel format, with its reliance on visual storytelling and condensed text, makes it difficult for some readers to grasp the full depth of the plot and character development- or to even identify characters in some scenes. Key moments that are more fleshed out in the original novel can feel rushed or unclear in this adaptation. Despite these challenges, I believe Silverwing: The Graphic Novel can still be a quality resource for visual learners and a great way to introduce Kenneth Oppel’s world to new fantasy readers.

Looking Up by Stephen Pastis- R

Looking Up by Stephen Pastis is a delightful addition to our library, perfect for middle-grade readers. I appreciate how Pastis seamlessly blends humor with deeper themes, making the story both laughter-provoking and thought-provoking for young readers. The protagonist, Saint, is a wonderfully relatable and quirky character who deals with complex emotions in a way that is accessible for children.

This book is not only a joy to read but also a valuable tool for teaching empathy and understanding. Pastis’ background in comics shines through in the witty dialogue and fast-paced storytelling, keeping students entertained and engaged while subtly addressing important life lessons. The community setting and the characters’ quest to save their town emphasizes the importance of togetherness and perseverance. Looking Up is a recommended addition to our shelves, offering both laughter and meaningful insights for our young readers.