A year has passed since Shiloh has become part of Marty’s family. It’s almost Christmas but the holiday spirit is low. Judd, Shiloh’s previous owner, is trying to be a better person, a new minister preaches more fire and brimstone than love, and a severe drought has made life harder. Marty and his family suspect the new pastor of hiding abuse of his daughters when they discover Rachel locked in a toolshed. A sudden wildfire destroys several houses and although Judd’s home is also burned, he is blamed for setting the fire. Marty’s parents offer Judd a place to stay while he rebuilds his house and searches for his dog. While uncomfortable, with the support of his family, Marty begins to see his community in a new light. As in the other books, the warm feelings of love, compassion, and family mingle with messages of tolerance and forgiveness. Despite being the last in a quartet, this book can stand on it’s own. Another wonderful read!